No construction work has followed the decision, and the issue went largely unnoticed until August, when Trinh Le Nguyen, executive director of the environmental NGO People and Nature Reconciliation (PanNature), began writing about it on Facebook. In a post dated Aug. 11, Nguyen noted that Tien Hai is part of the broader Red River Delta Biosphere Reserve. Established in 2004, the biosphere reserve spans 137,261 hectares (339,179 acres), including a core area, buffer zone and transition zone across terrestrial and marine areas. “The core area, the heart of the biosphere reserve, includes Tien Hai Nature Reserve and Xuan Thuy National Park,” Nguyen wrote.
No legal document specifying which technologies can or cannot not be imported to Vietnam exists. This ambiguity has hindered Vietnam from ‘filtering’ projects that could cause pollution.
Right after Da Nang City’s authorities rejected an investment project because it was believed to cause pollution, another province rolled out the red carpet to invite the investor to develop a project and lowered the required environmental standards.
Relating the story, Le Dang Doanh, former head of the Central Institute of Economic Management (CIEM), commented Vietnam must not let foreign investors bring outdated and polluting technologies to Vietnam and turn Vietnam into an industrial dumping ground.
Doanh noted that in Vietnam, local authorities measure local socio-economic development with the GDP growth rate, while they don’t pay appropriate attention to environmental protection.
In 2015, Thai Nguyen province took pride in its high growth rate of 93 percent thanks to the investment project developed by Samsung.
The industrial productivity in the province increased by 100 percent within one year, a very impressive figure. Therefore, Thai Nguyen has been praised for its great achievements in industrialization.
“However, we still need to consider the impact on the environment caused by the industrial productivity increase,” he commented.
According to Tran Thanh Thuy from PanNature (People and Nature Reconciliation), 67 percent of foreign invested enterprises (FIEs) in Vietnam operate in industries with low added value, while 80 percent of FIEs utilize mid-tier technologies and 14 percent use outdated technologies.
Only five percent of investors operate in modern industries such as information and communication, 5 percent in science & technology services, and 3.5 percent in insurance & finance sector which utilize modern management skills and high-quality labor force.
Meanwhile, according to the Foreign Investment Agency, only 28 investment projects have been registered in the water supply and waste water treatment sector since 1988, a very modest figure compared with the total 13,530 valid foreign direct investment (FDI) projects.
Since 2015, experts have repeatedly been warning about the new wave of FDI into the textile, dying and fiber industries in anticipation of TPP.
The Ministry of Planning and Investment (MPI) has also warned about the environment risks from the projects and asked local authorities to think carefully before licensing.
Nguyen Manh Hai from the Central institute of Economic Management (CIEM) commented that it is very difficult to fix environmental problems
“In many cases, we underestimate the cost to the environment if pollution is caused,” Hai said.
Vietnam has stated that it won’t accept outdated technologies. However, according to Nguyen Khac Kinh, chair of the Vietnam Environment Impact Assessment Association, the problem is that there is no legal document specifying which technologies can and cannot be imported.